What was Shridhar's fault?

Karan says all the 3 were at fault.. But I'm not convinced with the reason he gave for Shridhar being at fault! He might've covered up for Jules..he's supported her.. but he was being a good friend..he did try to stop her from going to the party..also try to stop her from taking up the modelling assignment.. He was only 17..still he tried his best to make her understand.. he cared for her.. What else he could do?

Karan says "wo usko samjha sakta tha..zyada se zyada dosti toot jaati, par ek ladki Gumrah hone se toh bach jaati" umm how would breaking the friendship help her?😕 He did though in anger but he was too sweet to literally break it. It was her fault and Prince for trying to kill him. what was he thinking? he was angry..but such a step in haste? Doesn't he know he would be jailed if caught? which was so easy to find out by the way. How does one's conscious allow it? specially when you are young you tend to be more sensitive towards ppl or at least scared to take any drastic step no matter how angry you are.. and here Prince had a family to look after..

Actually that was what even I was wondering during the epi. Shridhar never knew that Jules had gone to the extent of prostitution to achieve her ways. He came to know in the end just before they both died. There was nothing much he could have done since he was unaware of the whole picture.

Exactly! Shridhar had no idea about her business..what was he supposed to do?

btw..Shridhar does not die. He lives to tell the story..

Originally posted by: shibz

Exactly! Shridhar had no idea about her business..what was he supposed to do?

btw..Shridhar does not die. He lives to tell the story..

Even I wonder why Shridhar was blamed. He did what he could, but it didn't help. How is he at fault for that?

exactly.  that is why I am glad he lived.  I would be even more glad if Julie lived too. everyone should get a second chance and rectify mistakes. It is not like you err in life making decision life is over,  to err is human no. 

That's exactly what I thought too! One cannot really show the right path to someone through strong or aggressive persuasion...in fact, I think even parents fail when they use this approach to mend their child's ways. We can only advice people on what is wrong or right and Shridhar did that many times.  

^^Isn't it the script that Karan presents in his own words? but I agree Karan should've questioned how Shridhar was at fault! Did they have something else in mind  that we aint able to see?😕