Supernatural

|| Supernatural Online Reviews 9x11 Updated Page-5| - Page 4

HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 9.10 - Road Trip
by heydontjudgeme

http://heydontjudgeme.com/2014/01/15/supernatural-9-10-road-trip/
It's been awhile, huh?
Last we left everyone, Gadreel had
auditioned for the role of "Sam
Winchester" and nailed it, burn out
Kevin's light and bailed on Dean.
We've suffered for months, but for
Dean it's only been about an hour.
Bob Seger serenades us as Dean
gives Kevin a proper and respectful
hunter's funeral. It's all set up for a
beautiful montage, but instead of
Dean sifting through tomes while
wearing glasses we get him trashing
the room in a fitful burst of anger
and despair.
Let's give him a minute to regroup
and check in on Gadreel.
He's backstage at what sounds like a
One Direction concert, but turns out
to unfortunately be a Justin Bieber
cult gathering. The poorly-coiffed
and dressed singer is a vessel for
Thaddeus, Gadreel's previous
guardian in Heaven's Alcatraz.
Thaddeus tries to explain that his
excessive warden tactics weren't
anything personal, until Gadreel
brings up Abner. Thaddeus
acknowledges the closeness between
Gadreel and Abner, but almost
dispassionately tells Gadreel that he
enjoyed torturing Abner. Makes
sense that Gadreel and Abner would
be foxhole buddies, what with them
both being military men and all.
Gadreel doesn't have time for truces,
forgiveness or fights, he just kabobs
Thaddeus with his own angel blade
and the world is one spoiled celebrity
less.
Meanwhile, Castiel arrives at the
bunker to find it trashed. Dean finally
spills everything to someone and
accepts the possibility that in order
to fix this he may have to kill Gadreel
while he's in Sam. Castiel reminds
him that doing so will flash fry Sam
the Vessel, Dean says he knows that,
that's the one thing he's not a moron
about. He also admits that he was
stupid. Castiel tells him he was
stupid for the right reasons.
Wrong.
He was stupid for selfish reasons. I
mean, I'm all for his initial
selfishness of just wanting Sam to
live, but call a selfish spade a spade.
Moving on.
The only way they can think of to
boot Gadreel out so that Dean
doesn't have to gank his brother's
body is to somehow get Sam
cognizant enough to kick Gadreel's
ass out of Sam's brainpan. Castiel
tells Dean that he before he killed
Samandriel the kid told him that
Crowley had tortured him back to
reset. Okay, in all fairness, Castiel
left out the part where he committed
angelicide. Conveniently, they have
just the agony affliction artist for the
job.
Crowley is still shackled and grumpy.
Dean offers him a hit straight from
the vein for his help, but the King of
Hell has other demands. Like a bit of
pat-n-press from Kevin, but Castiel
simply tells him that Kevin is dead.
Crowley seems actually put off by
this, yet also smug, because he can't
say he didn't warn Kevin. Hang out
with the Winchesters and your
expiration date rivals milk. Crowley
next request is a field trip, basically
all Crowley seems to want is that his
meatsuit doesn't atrophy. Without
another option, Dean agrees. The
only problem is it seems Gadreel
stole the Impala and they're hoofing
it unless Dean gets a set of wheels.
If only he lived in a bunker with an
underground garage spilling over
with gorgeous, mint condition classic
cars. No worries, Castiel has a car,
but he abandoned it when it
randomly stopped chugging along.
Grumpy, Grumpier and His Royal
Smugness take a stroll to the car
and, like Dean suspected, it's only
out of gas. Dean fills up Castiel's g-
ride and the regulators mount up;
Dean in the front, Crowley and Castiel
cozied up in the back. They hook a
left on 21 and Lewis and bounce on
their way. What they don't notice is
the woman eyeing them up from the
curb. Turns out she works for
Abaddon and she's got a tale to tell.
Crowley has Dean take them to the
most corporate of buildings, but
according to him the business is a
front for the NSA to creepily clock
your every move, and not only that
but he has his very own demonic
wiretap, Cecily, working inside said
building. Cecily is fully aware of
Crowley's predicament, I mean, he
waltzed in with Dean Winchester and
Castiel in tow. Seems Cecily is
another demon that sees the sex
appeal in our fine-feathered friend.
Soon enough, Castiel calendars will
adorn every dungeon in Hell.
Crowley has Cecily track down the
whereabouts of the Impala and also
chats her up about Castiel's time as
a living breather and Abaddon's
hostile takeover. Cecily is willing to
help, but is honest about not picking
a side until the battle is won. Cecily's
tracks down Dean's penis metaphor
and they're off once again.
Metatron sits in a bar enjoying the
ambiance and a drink, because that's
what coldhearted asshats do. What's
interesting is who's serving at the
bar, it's Gadreel's pre-prime real
estate vessel. Gadreel walks in,
dumps a bag with the tablet on the
bar and announces that his targets
were officially targeted and while
killing Thaddeus was birthday cake
with extra frosting, killing Kevin went
down like a serving of gruel.
Metatron wants to know about Dean,
though. Well, duh, Gadreel tells him,
no one said, "hey, do me a solid and
kill Dean Winchester", so he's still
alive. Great employee that Gadreel,
but definitely not management
materiel. Metatron gives Gadreel
another name, Alexander Sarver, and
sends him off with a pat on the butt.
Alexander Sarver is primping his
perennials when Gadreel approaches
him, only when he turns around
Gadreel realizes that Alexander Sarver
is the vessel housing his BFF Abner.
And wow, is he not-so-lil-Abner.
Abner asks Gadreel to come back
after his family goes to the movies
so they can catch up. When he
returns, the two giant cherubs dish
what's what. Abner is a computer CS
agent with a family he loves and a
past he's learned from and moved
beyond, Gadreel killed Thaddeus. So,
y'know, same old, same old. Gadreel
is super proud of himself for
avenging them, but Abner is a little
disappointed. He feels like the fall is
their chance at a clean slate; he was
a lazy brat of an angel, but now he's
angel that took an abusive jackass of
a vessel and turned him into a
loving, and loved, family man. He's
not a smart man, but he knows what
love is. He tells Gadreel that's what
matters, finding what you care about
and clinging to it, no matter the
price.
So Gadreel slits his best friend's
throat. For his cause.
And that's how Dean and Castiel find
them, bloody body on the floor,
bloody hands getting washed clean
in the sink. Dean draws his angel
blade, ready to end it, but Gadreel is,
well, an angel, and easily flings Dean
into a bookcase. Thankfully, that
distracts him long enough for Castiel
to sneak up and sucker punch him.
Remember Cecily? Hope you didn't
get attached to her. See Abaddon
paid her a visit and, like Crowley, got
the scoop before it hit the papers.
Unlike Crowley, Abaddon doesn't
stand for fence sitting cowards and
dims Cecily's bulb all the way down.
Back at the lab, Gadreel is bound to
Crowley's reboot chair. Castiel is
confused because he doesn't
recognize who he is and Gadreel is
refusing to abide by social customs
and introduce himself. Dean is
feeling played and betrayed, he's
done; either this angel bails or this
angel gets bladed. Gadreel doesn't
seem to care either way. On the plus
side, it seems Gadreel has actually
been healing Sam and if they can get
Gadreel out of him then Castiel can
fix the rest. On the other plus side,
Gadreel has Sam working a faux-
case involving ghouls and
cheerleaders. Man, if only, huh,
Dean?
Dean gives the go-ahead and
Crowley starts playing Pop the
Bonnet with Gadreel/Sam's cranium.
Clearly it's painful and even though
it's not really Sam, Dean can't
handle the sight and sound so he
walks off. Castiel follows him and
distracts him by telling him that
doing what you have to do isn't
always easy, but it is always
necessary. Dean apologizes for his
behavior, however it's unnecessary;
Castiel gets it. Sam comes first. The
world can burn as long as Sam is
surrounded by water. Crowley
interrupts them to tune in Tokyo and
finally they get his name.
And Castiel is pissed.
Everything, literally everything that's
gone wrong in Castiel's long and
storied existence, down to Castiel's
daddy issues, is because Gadreel
screwed up a BC-ton years ago.
Dean pretty much has to pull Castiel
away before he pointlessly wrings
Sam's neck.
Crowley keeps trying to tweak the
tuning fork, but Gadreel comes back
to the surface and mocks his
attempts. Plan C is up on the table,
Dean demands that Castiel possess
Sam and tell him what's going on.
Great idea, except for the fact that
angel's require consent. Know who
doesn't? Demons. And Crowley is
more than willing to do it as long as
Dean is willing to deal: Crowley fixes
Dean's mess, Dean lets Crowley
walk. Castiel doesn't like this plan,
Dean doesn't care and once again
orders Castiel around like a puppy.
Castiel obliges and burns off Sam's
anti-possession tattoo so Crowley
can invade Sam's space. Dean tells
Crowley to say "Poughkeepsie" when
he finds Sam; apparently it's a real
Funky Town.
Let's take a quick census. Sam has
now been possessed by Meg, a
siren, Lucifer, an angry civil war
soldier, Gadreel, the Wicked Witch of
the West, and now Crowley. Three of
those were two at a timers. Did I
miss any? Talk about needing a
Silkwood shower with a Brillo pad
loofah.
Inside Sam's head, Sam is pouring
over his research trying to make a
connection between ghouls and
pom-pom when Crowley wanders in.
He quickly spits out the Winchester
safeword and explains everything,
just in time for Gadreel to show up.
Gadreel proceeds to kick Crowley's
ass and in a new twist, Sam saves
Crowley from Gadreel. Gadreel tries to
get Sam to give up control, tells him
that without him pulling the strings
the puppet is dead. Sam doesn't
care, whether it's agency or a death
wish he very literally gives Gadreel
the boot. Gadreel flees to the safety
of his original vessel.
Back in the land of the conscious,
Dean and Castiel unshackle Sam and
pull the pins out of his cushion, just
in time for Abaddon to show up.
Crowley does them one more favor,
he sends them out the back and
stays behind to chat up the prettiest
redhead in Hell. Crowley puts his
name on the ballot, he tells the
demons that he understands: without
a captain they drifted out to sea and
then along comes Mary and they
climbed on to her ship, but he's back
and if they make him student council
president he promises the cafeteria
will serve they're favorite flavor of
infant and they'll each get an afore
mentioned Castiel calendar.
Outside, Castiel heals Sam's botched
acupuncture and gives the brothers
some space. Dean is ready for Sam
to lay into him, but what's Sam
gonna say? That he's shocked Dean
lied to him? Today is Tuesday, too,
ya feel? In an interesting twist,
instead of Sam running away it's
Dean that decides to leave.
Everything he touches turns to dust
and he can't do it anymore. Sam lets
him go, but makes sure to tell him
that what he thinks is the problem
isn't really the issue, but he can go
and find himself.
Dean gets in his car and leaves Sam
and Castiel in the rain.

Created

Last reply

Replies

150

Views

13752

Users

5

Likes

117

Frequent Posters

HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
"Supernatural" Season 9 Recap:
"Road Trip"

http://lauinla.tumblr.com/post/73397369034/supernatural-season-9-recap-road-trip
Thanks to Andrew Dabb,
"Supernatural" kicked off 2014 with a
spectacular bang. "Road Trip"
crammed a lot of story (and angst)
into one action-packed hour, with the
whole enterprise anchored by Jensen
Ackles' powerhouse performance,
showing us a barely-restrained Dean
who hasn't been this close to the
edge since the Season 2 finale.
Last time the straits were this dire,
the elder Winchester sold his soul,
so it's fitting that "Road Trip" saw
him forced to make another deal with
the former King of the Crossroads to
save Sam's bacon.
The possibility of Crowley
possessing Sam to facilitate a
smackdown with Gadreel had never
crossed my mind before, but it
proved to be a masterstroke that
allowed Crowley to demonstrate a
modicum of his lingering humanity
along with his snark. That a demon
" especially one that's spent five
years trying to murder him " would
attempt to assuage Sam's guilt over
killing Kevin, instead of twisting the
knife even further, is a testament to
how much Crowley has evolved. He
really is the goodest guy the
Winchesters have got right now, and
the devil you know is certainly
preferable to the scorched earth
tactics of Abaddon. I particularly
loved that Crowley took the time to
seat himself in Sam's vacated chair
so that he could dramatically turn
around when Abaddon and her
cronies entered " ever the showman.
Vote Crowley!
While I feel like the Possessed Sam
storyline outstayed its welcome by a
couple of episodes, its climax
certainly made for a dramatic
midseason return; it was a joy to
witness the return of Tahmoh
Penikett, and I'm looking forward to
seeing what he does with the
character now that we know
Gadreel's true motivations. Seeing
Gadreel dispatch his supposed best
friend illustrated that there are
apparently no lines he won't cross to
get back to heaven and clear his
name, but I hope that he won't
become a clear-cut villain when
there's obviously some lingering
reluctance over what Metatron is
asking him to do. A little moral
ambiguity goes a long way.
Dean, Castiel and Crowley's awkward
road trip provided plenty of laughs,
even if I think a couple of the other
writers have an easier time with
Crowley's sharper barbs than Dabb
does. Mark Sheppard and Misha
Collins were given plenty of material
to work with, and their childish
bickering in the Impala was a
particular high point. But the episode
was a real showcase for Ackles, who
played Dean's agonized guilt and
desperation in a way that was utterly
gut-wrenching, especially in the
warehouse scenes where Crowley
was attempting to "hack" Gadreel to
get to Sam. Jared Padalecki has
done an admirable job of filling
Gadreel with menace while still
hinting at the inner-turmoil beneath,
but I'll be glad to have the real Sam
back, since we haven't seen him in
full command of his faculties and in
fighting form for a long time now.
A couple of the guest roles fell a
little flat for me; the actor who
played Thaddeus didn't quite sell his
smugness, although I appreciated the
Justin Bieber allusions; and Cecily's
Castiel obsession seemed out of
place, making the otherwise capable
character look a little too
schoolgirlish. The manufactured
humor of that situation felt forced
instead of organic (whatever
happened to demons and angels
finding each other repulsive,
anyway?), and it took me out of the
narrative momentarily.
But the real meat of the episode
came from the dynamics at play
among Team Free Will. Dean was
finally forced to stop lying to both
Sam and Castiel, and their differing
reactions proved fascinating.
One of my favorite aspects of
Castiel's character is his grace " not
the physical force that gives angels
their power, but the capacity for
forgiveness, mercy and patience that
many associate with divinity. Dean
has often rushed to judgment and
castigation whenever the angel has
made a mistake or chosen not to
confide his problems, but when their
roles were finally reversed, Castiel
didn't admonish or chide his friend,
instead simply telling Dean that he
was sorry and trying to reassure him
that he was "stupid for the right
reasons," a response he was no
doubt hoping to hear from Dean way
back in "The Man Who Would Be
King," when his own questionable
alliance with Crowley came to light.
No matter how many times he's been
betrayed, hurt or left out in the cold,
Castiel still demonstrates faith in the
inherent goodness of those he meets
" he wants to believe the best of
everyone, no matter how many times
he's seen people's manipulative,
selfish sides win out. While some
may view his trusting nature as a
weakness (or a sign that he's a
dumbass), to me, it's his greatest
strength. Not only is it lingering proof
of what God probably intended his
angels to be (there's a reason why
Cas keeps getting resurrected, after
all), it's a reminder for broken people
like the Winchesters that we can all
strive to be better, and that life would
be a lot easier if we were able to
trust our friends and family to love us
unconditionally instead of expecting
them to kick us when we're down.
Could all this have been avoided if
Dean had told Castiel the truth about
what he was intending to do with
"Ezekiel" and Sam from the start?
Maybe not " Sam probably would've
died if Gadreel hadn't hopped inside
him " but Kevin's death could surely
have been avoided, and at the very
least, Dean wouldn't have spent the
past nine episodes caught between a
rock and a hard place with no one to
talk to. Shoulda woulda coulda.
Sam's reaction was equally
compelling, especially since it was
far removed from the explosive,
violent outburst that Gadreel faked in
the previous episode. Part of Sam's
subdued reaction was likely due to
exhaustion, since his internal injuries
still weren't fully healed, but this is
also well-worn territory for the
brothers " they're locked in a
vicious cycle of lies and sacrifice,
continually driven by Dean's fear of
losing his family.
At this point, it's a a near-annual
tradition for the Winchesters to get
into a fight and go their separate
ways for a couple of episodes, but it
makes a change for Dean to be the
one leaving.
He's certainly running away for all
the wrong reasons " much as Sam
has done in previous years,
convinced that his demonic blood
has left him cursed in some way "
but I still think it's a good thing that
Dean chose to go and that Sam
didn't try to stop him. Judging by
Sam's confused reaction to Dean
vowing to take down Gadreel alone, I
doubt Sam would've stormed off or
forced Dean to leave him, which
implies that he might finally have
outgrown the "avoidance" method of
coping. I don't doubt that Sam needs
some space and doesn't necessarily
want to be stuck in close quarters
with Dean while he's processing, but
I'm impressed that his kneejerk
reaction wasn't to run away from the
problem.
Since the show began, Dean has
dragged Sam along with him because
he's been driven by insecurity and
afraid of being alone, in spite of
Sam's reluctance and his vocal
desire to escape the family business.
So even though Dean's decision to
leave comes from a place of guilt and
self-loathing, it's still a step in the
right direction that he's finally
realized he can't make Sam's
decisions for him, and that he
doesn't have the right to drag
someone into a fight just because he
believes it's the right thing to do. It'll
probably initially mean a return to the
self-destructive, alcoholic wreck we
saw in Season 7, but hopefully when
the pair reunite, they can finally have
a long-overdue conversation about
where they both stand and what they
need from each other in order to
salvage their relationship. I do wish
Sam had explained what he
considers to be the problem between
them, if it's not the fact that
proximity to Dean gets people killed
(something Sam can certainly relate
to, given his string of dead exes), but
perhaps it's better that Sam hits him
with that honesty after they've both
had some time to cool off.
While the brothers ostensibly chose
each other in the Season 8 finale, the
fact that Sam would've chosen to die
and Dean was unprepared to let him
illustrates that the duo still have
some work to do if they want to get
back on the same page, and I
continue to root for any character
development that allows the brothers
to be less codependent and more
respectful of each other's aspirations
and desires. As I've written before
and no doubt will again, I don't want
guilt, insecurity or emotional
blackmail to be the thing holding the
Winchesters together " it doesn't
mean that they love each other less
if they acknowledge that they have
different goals or interests.
While it's undeniably depressing to
see Dean revert to self-flagellation
whenever something goes wrong or
someone gets hurt, it's also a deeply
ingrained part of his character. From
his perspective, everyone leaves him,
so it's natural for him to assume that
it's his own failure that renders him
incapable of maintaining
relationships " something that's no
doubt been compounded by Sam's
reflexive desire to run away from his
problems and his brother. I'm just
hoping that the fact that Sam didn't
cut and run this time around might
help Dean to realize that their
relationship isn't as fragile and one-
sided as he's always believed, and
that he can't take responsibility for
the consequences of everyone's
choices any more than he should try
to make their decisions for them.
Pretty much everyone who's been
caught in the crossfire of the
Winchesters' ongoing war has
chosen to be part of the battle, fully
aware of the risks but determined to
fight the good fight regardless.
Carrying the guilt of their deaths is
human, but also diminishes the
agency of everyone from Jo and Ellen
to Bobby, who were willing to
sacrifice their lives for the sake of
the world, not because Dean
somehow forced them to get
involved.
It will be interesting to see whether
Sam and Castiel's interactions in
next week's episode help put the
Winchesters' relationship in
perspective. Cas has been observing
the brothers for long enough that
he's perfectly positioned to call them
both on their bullshit (as is Crowley,
albeit less gently " which is
probably what Dean needs right now)
. We all know that the Winchesters
balance each other out " and that
there'd be no show without them
together " so here's hoping that this
latest betrayal might finally teach
them a lesson that sticks.
It's admittedly tedious to see the
brothers repeating the same mistakes
over and over again, keeping secrets
and blindly sacrificing for each other
just for the sake of narrative drama,
so it would be refreshing for Season
9 to finally break that cycle and see
the boys as a wholly united front in
Season 10. It's hard to break the
habits of a lifetime, but it would be a
shame to see Castiel and Crowley
evolve so beautifully while our
heroes remain stagnant, and the
groundwork has certainly been laid
for the two to do some growing up.
It's long overdue.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 9.11 - First Born
by heydontjudgeme

When last we left the Winchesters
they were having their yearly
breakup. Dean drove off in the
Impala while Sam and Castiel
bounced to the bunker listening to
the dulcet sounds of N.W.A.
Jasper Springs, Mississippi, Civil War
era. Soldiers scramble to protect a
knight in a cabin. A knight? This is
America, not Medieval England.
Anyway, no sooner have the soldiers
flanked the door than a man saunters
in with a fancy knife and burns the
apparently demon soldiers back to
Hell. Interesting dude.
Back in the present, Dean is bellied
up to Metatron's generic bar, while a
generic waitress checks him out and
he smirks back sexily. Before she
can slip him a napkin with her
number on it, Crowley appears,
slightly stung that Dean's seduction
skills aren't aimed his way. Crowley
tells Dean that not only is the
waitress a clinical risk, but Gadreel
has squared away his tab and fluffed
off. He has a better way to while
away the hours by taking out
Abaddon. Dean is wary, not only do
he and Abaddon share ginger traits,
but Knights of Hell aren't exactly
killable. Crowley agrees, mostly,
however according to him there is
something that can punch her clock.
The "First Blade", the original Knights
of Hell execution weapon.
Crowley's been on the hunt for this
blade since the Stones first rolled,
but unfortunately his trail was
ganked by none other than John
Winchester, so Crowley flippantly
wonders if there's any info in Dean's
personal bible that would help out.
Smooth Crowley. Dean does find the
entry in John's Journal and a code
for a storage locker, that much like
the one in Mystery Spot is what,
magically paid up for all eternity?
Can Dean trust Crowley? Well, they
can either scratch at their matching
beards and see who can pitch their
voice the lowest or Dean can suck it
up and try.
He's not doing anything else anyway.
So he bags Crowley's head and they
head off to the storage unit. Crowley
is saddened that Dean doesn't trust
him, he's been in Sam after all,
doesn't that mean anything to Dean?
Not really, I'm sure. I mean, who
hasn't been inside Sam? That's a
shorter list.
Dean finds the info he needs. Turns
out John was hunting Abaddon's
little lackey with another hunter, Tara.
So they're off to find her.
Back the bunker, everything is
coming up domesticity; Castiel has
made himself a PB&J (crusts not cut
off, first misstep) and Sam apparently
went out for stuff and things. They
have a serious heart to heart about
how Castiel's sandwich tastes like
parts, not a sum. Sam dips his finger
into the sandwich to verify it's made
properly, it mostly is (crusts!), and
empathizes with Castiel's plight. In
thanks, Castiel tries to finish healing
Sam, but he can't. He tries to wave it
off with suberterfuge, but Sam calls
his lie out. Castiel is offended. Do
you know who you're talking to?
Castiel has successfully lied to and
betrayed you boys numerous times;
do not question his ability to
seriously snow you.
This time, however, he opts to be
straightforward. Castiel suggests
calling Dean for assistance, Sam
shoots that down. If Dean is off
wandering the desert, let him, he
knows where home is and Sam
hasn't changed the locks. So the duo
research on their own and Castiel
discovers a MOL document regarding
angel possession and its effects on
vessels. When an angel bails on its
vessel, for whatever reason, it leaves
a bit of itself behind. This fades over
time, but the document also gets into
the MOL theory that extracted the
grace could be made into an angelic
homing pigeon.
Only one, very sharp, way to find out
and after a quick lesson on human
colloquialisms they set off to find
scary ass, pre-modern medicine
needle pictured in the document.
Dean and Crowley have tracked Tara
down. Which isn't that hard
apparently, since it's her name on
the pawnshop storefront. She's not
exactly rusty though: shotgun behind
the counter, Devil's Trap under the
faux-fancy rug, holy water at the
ready. She's a bit thrown to find out
that John's lovely lil son is working
with a demon of his own volition.
She's not keen on Dean bringing a
demon to show and tell, but
nevertheless she offers up what she
knows. She has a spell to locate the
First Blade, but Whole Foods was all
out of Kraken essence.
Is that all? Crowley's got a surplus of
the stuff. And I'm really curious as to
why ?
Anyway, all the ingredients are
present and accounted for, time to
scry for a First Blade. Thankfully, it's
conveniently located in the United
States. Missouri, to be exact. Once
they've arrived, Crowley's venomy
senses start tingling and he
recognizes a force darker than his
own. Seriously, darker than the King
of Hell? Can only be one entity: The
Father of Murder, Cain, son of Adam
(or possibly of Lucifer, it's all still up
in the air, paternity tests are
pending), semi-professional keeper
of the bees. He seems to have the
bees under control though, no
swarming, no chasing from Seir to
Hormah. Just honey.
(fun fact: Seir La'Azazel is Hebrew
for "scapegoat")
Basically, what I'm saying is, if you
stare at your navel long enough, the
meta writes itself.
Moving on.
Crowley goes Hank McCoy on Dean
and explains that Cain was made a
demon after slaying Abel. He was
feared, rightly so, and then vanished.
Presumed dead. Cain comes back,
rumors of his demise, blah, blah,
greatly exaggeratedly, monosyllabic
blah, my tea floweth with milk and
honey and I want to know why you're
here, blah. Dean asks for the knife,
Cain dismisses him, literally.
Crowley, ever the logic seer, is ready
to tuck tail; Dean on the other hand
is a hunter first, a con artist and thief
second. Wait for Cain to run a few
errands and B&E what's rightfully, in
Dean's opinion, theirs.
So they do.
Of course, in the meantime,
Abaddon's henchman has been
tailing our bosom buddies. He's
offed Tara (people REALLY need to
stop helping the Winchesters, it
always ends goopy for them) and
tracked them to Cain's house.
Dean and Crowley come up with a
big, fat zero on the blade front, but
Dean does find a picture of a homely
woman with a ring to match Cain's.
Why do men do what they do? Give
up who they are? For a woman.
Always for a woman.
Before they can leave with their
insides where they go, Cain returns
and magically locks them in. Just in
time for Abaddon's crew to show up.
Cain's barricade will only last so
long, so Dean prepares to fight.
Cain opts to prepare dinner. What
more do you expect from the original
horticulturist? Dean demands to know
why he won't help, Cain is thoroughly
unimpressed. This is not the Dean
Winchester of legends. Does that
Dean still exist? Did he ever? Cain is
curious. So lets the demons in. And
watches passively as Dean, with a
wee bit of badassery from Crowley,
takes them out methodically. Cain
feels that he and Dean are kindred
spirits, Dean disagrees, because
while both where jealously of their
brothers and both deal with implied
incestuous undertones to their
relationships, Dean didn't kill Sam.
Dean feels like he's passed a test,
ergo he should get his prize, but
there is no prize, there is no Dana,
there is no blade.
The blade is nothing; it's the Mark of
Cain that powers it. The physicality of
it is nothing more than an old bone.
The same bone he murdered his
brother with because he was jealous.
Plot twist: turns out he wasn't. Abel
was well on his way to paving the
same path Sam was set to walk and,
like Dean, Cain put a stop to it. A
soul in Hell for a soul free from it,
Even Stevens. So Cain killed his
brother, sent him to Heaven and
began his reign in Hell. And he was
good. Until he met Colette. Of course,
she wanted him to give up his
friends for her. So he killed them.
Except for one.
Remember the Knight that the
demons were protecting in 1863?
That was Abaddon in Colette's body.
She offered, near begged, for Cain to
come back to her. He declined, so
she broke Colette from the inside and
fled. Cain swore revenge, but Colette
asked that she not be avenged. Very
altruistic of her.
Dean doesn't care. Just because
Cain is retired doesn't mean Dean is
ready to grow a beer belly and glue a
remote to his hand and his ass to a
recliner. He wants to end Abaddon.
Fine.
So Cain, against his storied
judgment, transfers the Mark to Dean,
tells him the blade is at the bottom of
the deepest ocean, lets the remaining
cadre of demons in, TARDISes them
out of the house, and lights it up.
Over in Kansas, Sam and Castiel are
discussing, well, Sam and Dean.
Castiel seems to think that the fact
that the brothers hauled off and
married each other in that church,
thus opting to hang out with one
another in lieu of closing the gates of
Hell, means something. Sam's still
jilted and now with added guilt, as if
there's anymore room in Sam
Winchester for MORE guilt. Maybe
having Castiel lipo Gadreel's grace
the rest of the way out will free up
some additional space. Castiel
begins the extraction, but he needs
more than he's willing to take. Taking
the full amount will mean Sam's
body goes back to pale on the
outside, extra crispy inside. Sam is
building a cross, Castiel is hiding the
wood. He doesn't want to kill Sam,
he wants to hang out with Sam,
maybe have Sam eat PB&Js and
describe them to him, who knows.
The fact is that Castiel, whether he
removed all he could or not, doesn't
think anything is worth trading Sam
Winchester's life for.
The Abomination himself finally has
the approval of the first angel he was
in awe of. What he had faith in now
has faith in him.
They try the spell, but it doesn't
work. Lack of grace. Sam and Castiel
hug out their feelings and it's kind of
beautiful really. Castiel vows to track
down and take out Metatron, but he
knows he may not be able to do it
alone. The implied, "hey Sam, call
your brother, ask him to come home
to you", is only barely implied.
Crowley and Dean have their own
heart to heart. See Crowley knows
that no matter how much he and the
demons and the monsters and the
angels loathe Dean, no one does so
more than Dean himself. Not that
he's wrong, but Dean isn't stupid, he
knows Crowley worked this
chessboard like Bobby Fischer.
Crowley doesn't deny it or the fact
that he could care less about the
collateral damage. He'll find the
blade, they'll all samba over
Abaddon's corpse and then it's game
on.
Of course the real question is, the
ocean breathes salty, so how is
Crowley gonna pull this one off?
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 9.11 "First Born"
Review: To Each His Own Atonement
by spoilertv

This week's episode of Supernatural,
"First Born," was written by Robbie
Thompson and directed by John
Badham. Badham is perhaps best
known as the director of Saturday
Night Fever . The episode guest stars
Timothy Omundson as Cain.
Omundson delivers a wonderful
performance, and while he's been a
friend to the Supernatural family for
some time, this episode ensures that
he is now very firmly a part of the
family proper.
The episode is a bit of a change up
and sees Dean (Jensen Ackles)
paired with Crowley (Mark Sheppard)
while Sam (Jared Padalecki) pairs
with Castiel (Misha Collins). Dean,
Sam, and Castiel are all suffering
from low self-esteem and are
focusing on their short-comings.
Crowley, of course, is perfectly happy
to capitalize on Dean's weaknesses.
Once again, when he's at a low point,
Dean forgets his better judgment
never to trust or work with a demon.
Crowley tells Dean, "nobody hates
you like you hate you." Cas tries to
get Sam to see that he'd agreed with
Dean to live instead of closing the
gates of Hell and that his life is
precious. By the end of the episode,
it seems they are each hunting for
someone else: Castiel for Metatron,
Dean for Abaddon, and Sam for
Gadreel.
There are lots of mirror images in this
episode besides the new pairings.
Sam is consumed with not letting
anyone else be hurt because of him
and is still feeling responsible for
Kevin's death. Dean is also still
convinced that anyone close to him
is doomed to die or be hurt, and
Tara's (Rachel Hayward) death
simply reinforces that belief. John's
one weekend stand with Tara is
mirrored by Dean's attempts to
seduce the waitress. There are two
spells in the episode - one works to
find the first blade, but the other fails
to find Gadreel. Both Crowley and Cas
suggest at the end of the episode
that they will need more help to
catch their quarry, and both Sam and
Dean decline to include the other.
Cain's story could also easily be
Dean's. Cain kills his brother to save
him from Lucifer and assure his soul
went to Heaven while damning his
own to Hell. Dean went to Hell in
exchange for Sam's life and also had
to save Sam's soul from Lucifer.
Colette (Anna Galvin) could easily be
Lisa. Colette knew who Cain was and
what he'd done and she loved him
unconditionally. All she wanted was
for him to stop the killing. Lisa knew
who Dean was and what he'd done,
and all she wanted was for him to
stop - although she tried to make it
work with him hunting. If Colette
looked familiar, it's because Galvin
also played Mrs Fremont (child-
Lilith's mother) in "No Rest For the
Wicked." Interesting that the actor
would have this dual connection to
Dean/Hell/murder.
A quick word about Tara who was
brilliantly brought to life by Hayward.
It's always great to see another
woman hunter - even if having a
Winchester enter her life pretty much
seals her fate. Tara was smart, brave,
and clearly independent. Hayward
certainly looks like she could hold
her own in a fight. However, she also
admits to the classic hunter failing -
obsession. She ends up with a bum
knee all alone and her life ruined
because of chasing the blade
unsuccessfully all over the world.
It was great seeing John Winchester
play a part in this episode. We see
that Dean still carries John's journal
with him and is still stung when Tara
points out that John would have
been extremely disappointed in Dean
for working with a demon. I loved
that they've added codes to where
John stored more information on the
entries. It never made sense for the
sum total of John's 22 years of
hunting to fit into that journal. After
all, Dean and Sam have been hunting
for nine years on the show and their
hunts would fill more than that
journal. I loved how what the "T"
stands for is revealed to be Tara. I
do have to wonder why they haven't
simply gathered all of John's
materials into the bunker - even if
they have been busy.
Cas reflects on what being human
did to him. He was able to
experience life in a completely
different way, but now that he's an
angel again his perspective has
changed again. When it comes to
PB&J, he can't see the forest for the
trees - he can only taste molecules
(trees) not the entire sensation of the
sandwich. Yet, he at least remembers
that his sensations and feelings were
different so he has a new
appreciation for the sanctity of life
and how Sam feels. Old Cas would
have drained the life out of Sam, but
new Cas sees Sam as an individual
and sees worth in that - which is
why seeing his PB&J stops Cas from
continuing. His hope is that angels
can change, so maybe even pig-
headed Winchesters can too.
He is still quintessentially Cas
though. He is hilariously offended
when Sam tells him he's a terrible
liar, quickly pointing out that he
managed to deceive Dean and Sam
very effectively when he was working
with Crowley. Collins is fantastic at
bring yet another level of
characterization to Cas. He also still
has his completely ingenuous
moments, such as his hopeful joy
that Sam has a guinea pig stashed
somewhere in the bunker and his
failing to understand Sam's teasing
about asking a question. It's a lovely
moment when Sam hugs Cas and has
to coach him through hugging back.
Cas asks Sam about his choice to
stop the trials and live. Sam agrees
that he did choose to live, but then
simply continues that Dean made a
choice for him after that. Sam then
goes on to say that he could have
put a stop to everything and closed
the gates of Hell. Yet, his death after
stopping the trials would not have
closed the gates of Hell. Dean didn't
cause the gates of Hell to remain
open OR the angels to fall by letting
Gadreel possess Sam. It did,
however, lead to Kevin's death. Sam
may feel that he needs to avenge
Kevin's death, but he can hardly be
responsible for what Gadreel did
while in possession of Sam's body. I
found this scene disappointing, and I
hope this will be addressed further.
Being human means settling your
debts, according to Sam and he
wants to start balancing the books.
Padalecki brings a new layer to his
portrayal of Sam in the episode as
we see his desperation to fix what he
can.
Crowley, played exquisitely by the
King of Genre Sheppard, has, as
always, many of the episode's best
lines. I loved him crossing himself
when Cain displays his mark and his
teacup rattling as he shares tea with
Cain. It is always a joy to watch
Crowley work both sides against the
middle. Dean recognizes that Crowley
has played him. I'm still curious
about Crowley's addiction to blood.
Has he really changed in some
fundamental way? Does he maybe
want to return to being King of Hell to
shut the gates himself? Or does he
want to make it a kinder and gentler
version of Hell than what it would be
under Abaddon? Was he simply trying
to water his demon blood down
enough to escape the various demon
traps he was ensnared in?
It was nice to see Dean figuring out
some of the puzzle on his own. He
pieces together Cain's motivation
when he finds Colette's photo and
makes the connection to Cain's ring.
He left his life of destruction for the
love of a woman. Omundson is
wonderful in the scene in Colette
dies and then he asks her
forgiveness before rejoining the fight.
It's a lovely touch when he kisses
the ground over her grave.
Ackles and Omundson really pushed
each other to their best work. I loved
Omundson simply watching as he
tests Dean's reputation as brave but
impulsive. The fight scene was
amazing and Ackles shot the entire
scene himself with no stunt doubles.
I was a little disappointed in all the
super close-ups and cuts that
interrupted really seeing what was
going on at times - but that is, as
always, my person complaint about
such scenes.
It was inevitable that we would draw
parallels between these two first born
sons. Dean has identified himself as
a killer for a very long time, and Cain
is the father of murder. However, in a
great Supernatural twist, we see that
Cain didn't murder his brother
without a good reason. In every way
that matters, Cain saved his brother's
soul.
One interesting possible influence on
the episode is Neil Gaiman's
Sandman series which features a
character, Destruction, who appears
in Brief Lives and Endless Nights .
Crowley, of course, has been linked
to the Good Omens novel that
Gaiman co-wrote with Terry
Pratchett. The character is described
as having a large beard and having
abandoned his responsibilities,
retiring to the country. Destruction
dedicates himself to trying to create
rather than destroy - much like
Cain's concern for the bees as life
on earth will end if all the bees die.
Destruction even cooks a last meal
for his guests before he disappears
again. In Brief Lives , Destruction tries
to counsel another character on the
need to change and self knowledge.
There's another comics reference as
Dean and Crowley enter the pawn
shop and Tara is reading Joe Hill's
comic series Locke & Key (see
picture above). The first series was
called Welcome to Lovecraft - a name
we've heard before on Supernatural.
Dean is determined to kill Abaddon.
He is willing to pay "the great cost"
that carrying Cain's mark will force
upon him if it means he can "kill the
bitch." Like Cain, killing simply leads
to more killing, and perhaps this is
the lesson that Dean needs to learn.
Sam needs to learn to forgive - both
himself and his brother. It was an
interesting twist to see Dean take on
Cain's mark, I hope we won't have to
wait too long to find out what the
burden might be. I have to wonder if
it is going to be the inability to die
himself. The demon knife does not
kill Cain and the legend is that Cain
cannot be killed. I loved the shout
out to Saturday Night Fever as Dean
tells Cain "Let's dance" as he clasps
his arm. Kudos to the VFX team for
the terrific effect of the transfer of the
mark.
Cain's demand that Dean come to
him and kill him when he calls seems
like it's too easy a request. Will Dean
have become sick of killing by then?
Will the call mean he can't protect
someone else? Only time will tell, but
it does seem to promise that we will
be seeing Omundson again. The
mark is obviously physically paining
Dean, so it will be interesting to see
if that continues and its other
effects. Anybody else think that Sam
is going to be pretty upset with his
brother when he sees it? I'm betting
Cas will also have a few choice
words for Dean.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 911 Recap - Bees,
Blades, and Beliebers

Let's not bury the lead here. This is
the first episode of Supernatural
since Jared Padalecki took to twitter,
made a comment about Justin Bieber,
and started a bit of a war. (All of the
concerning tweets and jokes and
fandom response is well documented
on Tumblr if you missed it.) Whether
this incident had any real impact on
the show is hard to know, but the
ratings from last night are in and TV
by the Numbers has determined that
First Born was the most watched
episode of the show since 2010s
Weekend at Bobby's.
Let's all go out and celebrate by
egging our neighbors' houses!
Instead of last night's episode being
split into an A and B story where one
is secondary to the other, they
instead kept up with one another
more closely than usual. Fans could
make a good case for Dean's story
being the larger one, but they were
both impactful enough that I accept
them as equals. Also each one of
them can stand on its own, so we'll
tackle them separately.
In the plot-driven Dean storyline:
Crowley surprises Dean at a bar in
the BEST MANNER POSSIBLE:
( x )
Me too, Crowley.
Turns out that the best bet to kill
Abaddon is something called the First
Blade. Crowley had a demon tracking
it, but at one point that demon was
killed by Papa Winchester. So Dean
checks "the John Winchester
Memorial Library" and a clue in the
journal has the unlikely duo off to
search one of John's storage
lockers. That locker leads them to a
hunter named Tara (raise your hand
if you knew she was a goner the
second you saw she was a badass
lady), who leads them to a spell
which leads them to Missouri (the
state not the medium), which leads
them to Cain. Yeah. That Cain.
Now everything up until Cain was an
interesting experiment in Crowley-
watching. We all know he is not to be
trusted, but it's becoming more and
more obvious that he's grown
attached to the Winchesters. He may
not like the brothers per se, but he
enjoys the banter and the excitement
that surrounds their time together.
Whether he is trying to get Dean to
teach him John's journal code, or is
offering to fetch some essence of
Kraken, or proclaiming himself
Dean's bestie -
( x )
there always seems to be a childlike
glee in the King's eye. Whether this
is a side-effect of the human blood
or just of being exiled from Hell is
anyone's guess.
Cain, according to Crowley, was
turned into a demon after killing his
brother and from then on became the
greatest of murderers. Cain later
explains that he's not only the one
that took out the Knights of Hell, but
he's the one who created them as
well. However, he has no interest in
helping Dean and Crowley. Not even
when the pair of them begin to be
attacked by a horde of Abaddon's
demons. We were treated to a frankly
amazing fight scene, and then it was
story time.
Cain shows off his Mark (with a
capital M) and explains that without
the Mark the blade is useless. And -
big biblical twist here kids - Cain
killed Abel to save his soul. To keep
his brother from becoming Lucifer's
pet, he made a trade, one that
involved Cain being the one to send
his brother's soul on to Heaven. His
subsequent years of slaughter only
ended when he met his wife Colette,
and when the Knights showed up he
killed them all. Save Abaddon.
Because she was wearing his wife as
a suit. After that, Cain tossed the
blade to the bottom of the deepest
sea and began his seclusion.
This goes all the way back to Gabriel
explaining Destiny (with a capital D)
to Dean in Changing Channels. In
that tale, he and Sam were Michael
and Lucifer; later Michael himself
revealed that their bloodline went
back to Cain and Abel. And while
Dean would Never (capital N) kill
Sam as Cain did his brother - well
doesn't that scenario change if what
Cain actually did was save his
brother's immortal soul.
PLEASE WRITERS.
PLEASE.
DO NOT WANT FRATRICIDE THIS
SEASON.
NO THANK.
VERY NOT.
But alas, Dean takes on the Mark of
Cain (I was yelling at the TV because
BOY OH BOY does this seem like a
bad plan). Crowley, we discover, was
playing the frightened puppy act to
trick Dean into getting the Mark
(raise your hand if that didn't
surprise you in the least), but Dean
sends him to retrieve the blade
anyway.
p.s. If Dean does not tell Sam and
Cas about the Mark on his arm, so
help me, I will HUNT DOWN THE
BLADE AND KILL HIM MYSELF.
...
He's not going to tell them, is he?
*weeps*
In the emotionally-driven Sam
storyline:
Cas waxes philosophic about his lost
love for PB&J.
( x )
(Raise your hand if you had NO IDEA
how important that damn sandwich
was about to become.)
Cas is sticking with Sam in order to
help him heal. But while healing him,
he discovers that there is a bit of
grace left behind by Gadreel inside of
Sam. They find that the Men of
Letters believed it possible to extract
the grace from a former vessel, and
with that grace the ability to perform
a summoning ritual to find the angel.
Cas is hesitant to do this because
the procedure is purportedly painful
and there had yet to be a success.
But Sam is a Winchester, which
means he is guilt-ridden and needs
to toss himself into a fire every so
often or else he gets cold.
They begin the extraction; Cas
quickly realizes the process is
sending Sam back to his state pre-
Gadreel, but our beloved Moose
refuses to let Cas stop the process.
No matter how many life-affirming
quips the angel sends his way, Sam
just refuses to budge. You know -
because the guilt is so heavy he
can't move? Finally, Cas looks over
his shoulder at the sandwich (THIS
IS NOT A JOKE) and comes to
realization. He stops the extraction
and heals Sam.
Cas : Sam, I want Gadreel as
much as you do. But nothing is
worth losing you. Being human
didn't just change my view of
food. It changed my view of
you. I mean I can relate now to
how you feel.
Sam: What are you talking
about?
Cas : The only person who has
screwed things up more
consistently than you is me.
And now I know what that guilt
feels like. And I know what it
means to feel sorry, Sam. I am
sorry
Sam: I know.
Cas : You know old me I would
have just kept going. I would
have jammed that needle in
deeper until you died because
the ends always justify the
means. But what I went
through? That PB&J taught me
that angels can change. So
who knows? Maybe
Winchesters can too.
Not to quote myself in a recap but
"Angels can change. Maybe
Winchesters can too." Put that
shit on my tombstone. #
Supernatural
" Leah Cornish (@Leah617)
January 22, 2014
Now Cas tells Sam that he got as
much grace out as was there, but
I'm fairly sure that Cas lied (better
than normal) because he didn't want
to do Sam any more harm. That he's
able to flawlessly lie here, but wasn't
earlier? Well it shows just how damn
much Sam means to Cas and NO
ONE TOUCH ME I'M NOT CRYING I
JUST HAVE SOME SASTIEL IN MY
EYE.
The ritual doesn't work, which is a
shame because I was hoping for my
episodic dose of Tahmoh Penikett,
and Sam admits that Cas was right.
And then nothing else happens. Nope
nothing at all.
Of course I'm lying because HUG
happened:
( x )
Cas finally got his Sam hug and he
had NO IDEA what to do with it.
Bless.
The important come together moment
of both of these storylines OF
COURSE was the fact that the
brothers seem determined to go their
paths separately.
( x )
And both of their companions -
angel and demon alike - realize what
the whole fandom has known from
the get go. The Winchesters are
better together.
Other favorite moments of the
episode:
( x )
QUICK SOMEONE WRITE ME THE FIC
WHERE SAM BUYS CAS A PET GUINEA
PIG.
This moment, that according to
Robbie Thompson was an ad lib
made by Mark Sheppard.
( x )
That right there is the campaign
slogan for Crowley 2014.
Then there was this gem that I totally
missed on first viewing. Right after
Crowley sees the Mark of Cain:
( x )
I had to pause the video I was
laughing so hard.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 911
Review: First Born

As upset as I was with the
Winchesters parting ways yet again,
this split has offered opportunities
for rarely seen character dynamics to
thrive. Mark Sheppard and Jensen
Ackles nailed it tonight and I was
thrilled with every scene they shared
together. Misha Collins and Jared
Padalecki also had a lot of fabulous
scenes in tonight's episode. Despite
the fact that Misha is my favorite
actor on the show, I feel like their
scenes were definitely second to the
amazing chemistry between Ackles
and Sheppard. Amazing
performances all around. The
episode wasn't without its problems,
though. Once again the show
introduces a promising female
character only to take all of our
hopes away. As incredible as the
rest of the episode was, this whole
situation really put a bad taste in my
mouth.
My favorite moments of the episode
all came from Crowley and Dean.
Crowley is definitely evil. He's an
antagonist and he's killed people and
that's not something that can be
overlooked. Morally I should be
completely against him teaming up
with the Winchesters for anything,
but this doesn't stop me from
enjoying every moment that he's on
screen. Once again I find myself
desperately wishing he wasn't so
darn evil so that he could actually be
a permanent member of Team Free
Will. He adds a sardonic humor to
every scene he's in that I find
incredibly appealing. There's always
a dark humor running throughout the
show generally, but the dryness of
Crowley's quips are hard to beat. In
season 5 Crowley teamed up with
them to take out Lucifer and now
he's teaming up with them to go
after Abbadon. It seems that if you
compare him to the other evils that
exist in the world, he's definitely the
lesser of them. He's still evil,
though, and as viewers it's easy to
forget that as we get lost in Mark
Sheppard's amazing performance.
Jared Padalecki and Misha Collins
are always fabulous together, but
they rarely get scenes alone. In the
past this has been blamed on their
penchant for playing pranks on each
other on set and I am no doubt
looking forward to the gag reel, but
this has come at a sacrifice of the
characters' relationship. This
episode more than made up for it
though. Castiel has learned a vital
lesson thanks to a combination of the
Winchesters and a peanut butter and
jelly sandwich. Castiel has grown as
a person over the years and no
longer has the same outlook he did
even as recently as last season. The
ends no longer always justify the
means for him. Sam and Castiel
bond over their shared trait of
screwing things up and their
friendship develops into something
even stronger than it was before.
I'm looking forward to more.
Unfortunately this episode didn't thrill
me all the way through. This season
has continued with the very strong
trend of killing off their new strong
female characters within the episode
they are introduced and I was hoping
we'd start moving away from that.
As soon as a new strong female
character was presented to us I
began pleading "please don't die."
This episode was written by Robbie
Thompson and he generally treats his
female characters fairly well so I had
high hopes. He's the one that
created Charlie, after all, and he
crafted Dorothy into an incredibly
badass character just a few episodes
ago. Even the writer that I hold in
such high regard isn't immune from
the occasional misstep it seems. If
this had been the first instance of the
season where this occurred I may
have been more forgiving, but the
show itself has a bad history of this
exact type of thing and I've become
hyper aware of just how often it
happens.
Despite the mistreatment of the new
female character, the episode did
manage to introduce a new male
character that shows a lot of
promise. Cain is being framed as a
surprisingly intriguing ally given that
he's typically framed as a simplistic
villain. Once more Supernatural has
taken religious lore and twisted it in
a fresh new way. It seems as though
he'll be playing a vital part in this
seasons overarching plot, which
seems to be shifting focus now that
we've reached the halfway point.
Whereas during the first half of the
season the fallen angels and Gadreel
dominated the ongoing plot, it seems
the battle between Crowley and
Abbadon is taking center stage for
the back half. I'm generally happy
with the shift in focus as the first half
of the season was very disappointing
and I love both Crowley and
Abbadon, but I am sad that this
means the chances of seeing
Tahmoh Penikett reprise his role as
Gadreel is getting slimmer.
Overall this episode was far better
than almost any episode in the first
half of the season. I'm disappointed
that the brothers are still apart and
that the trend of mistreating female
characters is continuing, but there's
a lot of promise for the back half of
season 9 to improve. In order to
keep this momentum going they need
to focus on what they want the
central plot to be, add some
permanent female energy in the
dynamic (bring back Jodie or Charlie,
perhaps?), and get the Winchesters
back together. Once they get these
issues sorted season 9 can live up
to the expectations Supernatural fans
have set for the show that we love so
much.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Review: Supernatural 9x11 "First
Born"

We find Dean sitting in a dinner by
himself and Castiel feeding Sam
angelic chicken noodle soup. They
have gone their separate ways for
the time being. Dean is holding to
his "keep Sam out of it" plan and
Sammy likewise is refusing to call
Dean for help. I can say though
unlike in the past, a few days apart
and no one has ended up tied to a
tree... yet. Perhaps its because they
aren't completely on their own this
time. They've found new partners for
the time being. I don't think Dean is
going to keep his partner longer than
he really needs too. He's not a big
fan of his truth be told.
Sidenote: I am resisting a huge urge
not to just quote the entire show
below. It was a very quotable
episode.
Sidenote2: I'm also not going to
make a reference to that small
kerfuffle that occurred between a
certain fanbase and a cast member,
but I will say, way to go SPNFamily
for making this week's episode one
of the most watched episode in
years.
Castiel finds something a wee bit
interesting while he's healing Sam.
It seems Gadreel left a sort of angelic
fingerprint (I personally would have
called it a footprint, but they didn't
ask me). He's got a smudge of
grace left in him. Grace that could
be used for a tracking spell to lead
them to Gadreel. The only thing is,
extracting the grace will harm Sam,
but healing Sam will get rid of the
grace all together.
Crowley shows up and begs Dean to
star in a Buddy Comedy with him.
There is a weapon that can kill
Abaddon. It's called "The First
Blade" and it is what the archangels
used to fight the Knights of Hell.
There's only one problem. The
closest Crowley ever got to the blade,
were rumors that one of his demons
had gotten close to it, a demon who
was smoked by dear old Pappa
Winchester before Crowley could get
to him. This is the bit where I
screeched at the sight of John's
journal. I just missed that old
raggedy thing, okay? It reminds me
of simpler times of women in white
and wendigos.
The journal leads them to John's
files, which lead them to Tara, an old
hunting buddy. Now is the bit that I
try not to rage too hard on the fact
that as soon as we met her and I
realized that I really loved her, that I
knew I had seen the last of her. Like
seriously, can we not? No. I'm really
asking now. Can we please just not?
Tara was cool. She was confident.
She was a badass. She had a knee
that twinged when a demon was
nearby!
Tara gives them a tracking spell
which leads them to the power
source of "The First Blade". There
we find Timothy Omundson , I mean
Cain. That's right Cain as in Cain
and Abel. After Cain killed his
brother, he became a demon. He
became the "Father of Murder" and
he trained the Knights of Hell. He's
pretty freaking powerful and really
deadly. Then one day, he retired.
He was out of the game. He found
a woman who loved him, but that
wasn't good enough for his knights.
So he picked up his blade one more
time and salughtered them all.
Except for Abaddon. She was able
to escape when she distracted him
with the murder of his love, Collete.
In the mythology of Supernatural, this
is not the first time that Cain and
Abel have been referenced. Sam and
Dean have been compared a few
times before, but we've never had the
entire story before. We didn't know
all the facts. Cain didn't kill his
brother out of jealous. He killed him
to save him.
"He said that I had to save you [...]
and that if I couldn't I'd have to kill
you." - Hunted 2x10
Abel wasn't speaking with God, it
was Lucifer. So Cain did what he
could, he made a deal with the devil.
Abel's soul goes to heaven in
exchange for Cain's soul. The catch
being that Cain had to send Abel
onto heaven himself.
After a quick stunt demon vs.
Winchester showdown, Cain reveals
he had felt a connection between
them since he walked in the door.
He'll give Dean the Mark. The Mark
of Cain, the source of the blade's
power. He'll be able to kill Abaddon,
but of course it comes with a price.
A price we don't know what yet. I'm
guessing it's not sunshine and
lollipops. Cain asks for only one
thing in return. That when the time
comes, Dean will use the blade on
him after he's killed Abaddon.
While Dean is gaining some traction
on his Abaddon problem, Sam is not
fairing so well. The extraction of the
grace, is taking too much out of
him. Castiel still remembers what
it's like to be human and knows what
it means to make horrible decisions
while trying to do good. Seriously
bad decisions in the name of good.
As a human he had to live with that
burden on his shoulders. Castiel
knows empathy for the first time.
So , now he can't bring himself to
do whatever it takes, especially if it
comes at the cost of Sam's life.
There will be other ways to find
Gadreel.
Favorite bits of the episode?
Timothy Omundson!!
Just about every single line that
came out of Crowley's mouth.
Some of the winners being:
"I do love a good buddy comedy."
"I've been inside your brother. We're
practically family."
"[...]domestic partner in crime[...]" Can
we get that on coffee mugs or
something?
"You're good, but I'm Crowley."
Crowley telling Tara that him and
Dean are besties.
Castiel's excited face when he
thought that Sam had a guinea
pig and then disappointment
when he realized it was a
metaphor.
Castiel x Pb&J = OTP. From his
disappointment at only tasting
molecules to his remembrance
of what it meant to be human, it
all hit my Cas soft spot.
This is how I saw it: "The King
of Hell and a Winchester walk
into my house ... *John Bender
falls through the roof*... I forgot
my pencil."
Crowley crossing himself at the
sight of Cain's mark. You know
things are bad when the Kind of
Hell crosses himself (yes I know
he was playing Dean the entire
time, but come on that's never a
good sign).
"Why must the Winchesters run
toward death?"
SAM AND CASTIEL HUG! HOW
LONG HAVE I BEEN WAITING FOR
THAT? AND HOW MAGICAL WAS
IT?! JUST. I AM SO GLAD THAT
WE ARE FINALLY GETTING SOME
SAM AND CASTIEL BONDING
TIME. LIKE ITS SO WONDERFUL
AND I LOVE IT!
In conclusion: Demon and angel alike
think that Sam and Dean need to just
suck it up and call their brother. As
humans we should all appreciate
peanut butter and jelly (NOT jam)
sandwiches just a little bit more.
Even the King of Hell can't resist
Dean Winchester's charm and
regardless of what Dean says there is
always enough time for a Winchester
and King of Hell buddy montage.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 9.12 - Sharp Teeth
by heydontjudgeme


Grantsburg, Wisconsin. This week's
episode opens up on a farm in the
middle of the night. According to the
closed captioning what we're hearing
is snarling, howling, the dulcet
sounds of flesh rending and cows
mooing. Apparently there wasn't
enough cowbell to make the closed
captioning cut.
Seeing as it's the dead of night, the
owner of the farm is none too
pleased with the disruption and
comes out blazing. The figure that
abandons his prime offal is scrawnier
than the sounds indicated he'd be.
He takes off running, jumping fences,
dodging trees, just trying to get away,
contemplating nothing but escape
and finally making it... until the he
runs into the road and high-fives a
car.
Oh look, it's Garth.
A few days later Sam arrives at the
Grantsburg Memorial Hospital in full
FBI garb. He flashes his badge and
requests to see Mr. John Doe. The
nurse at the station barely gives his
magnificent hair or his badge a
glance before giving him the room
number. She also says John Doe is a
popular dude. Obviously, when Sam
enters the room he's face to face
with his estranged brother.
Okay, so this nurse spoke to Sam and
Dean Winchester, separately, and was
that blas? As if hot, scruffy dudes
and hot, fed suited dudes just waltz
in and out all day?
Whatever. Back to Sam and Dean,
who are acting less like brothers and
more like exes running into each
other for the first time since their
break up. Which is ridiculous, they
breakup every year. Garth is
handcuffed to the bed, charged with
offing Clarabelle. Dean tells Sam that
he's got this and Sam can skedaddle,
but Sam is reluctant, Dean hasn't
even spoken to Garth and Garth is so
dosed out on morphine he's halfway
to Wall Street. Dean is ready to give
him a Mia Wallace special, but Sam
is uncomfortable with that and
backhands Garth awake.
Garth seems happy to see Sam and
Dean, actually thinks he might be in
heaven, until his stomach stages a
revolt against him. Good thing Sam
picked Garth's handcuffs open.
The brothers sit and wait for Garth to
stop revisiting everything he's ever
eaten and actually talk a bit. Sam
tells Dean about the grace tracer that
Gadreel left in him and how Castiel
helped snuff it out and Dean tells
Sam all about his fancy new Mark of
Cain. This is all very open and
honest and I'm a mix of proud and
uncomfortable. Unfortunately, Garth
bolted out the window during their
dramatic tell-all, ditched his gown,
nabbed a car, and fled the scene.
Hopefully the surveillance camera
can give them some answers. Dean
offers to check and suggests that
Sam go talk to the farmer.
The farmer tells Sam that his animals
have been getting gutted for a while
now and not just the simple throat
ripped out kind of stuff, but organs
only, paint the walls, Marilyn
Manson-looking type stuff. Oddly
familiar. Meanwhile, Dean hits the Big
Brother jackpot: Garth, the car he left
in, full-view license plate, complete
with easily traceable registration and
a handy-dandy address for the
owner, Bess Meyers. All which he
fails to disclose to Sam when he
calls to check in. Sam, however, is
right around the corner and walks
into Dean holding the info he's
claiming not to have.
Dean Winchester, you sit on a throne
of lies. You wear a crown of
subterfuge and carry a scepter of
fallacies. You also haven't shaved.
Which, I mean, I get it, it would cut
into your angsting time. The longer
the scruff, the deeper the self-
loathing. And the deeper the self-
loathing the more the audience is
supposed to forget your creepy
controlling tendencies. But we'll get
into that later.
Right now, let's get back to Sam and
Dean bursting into Bess Meyers'
humble abode. There's no Bess to be
seen, but there is Garth standing in
the middle of the kitchen talking at
the boys, but clearly to someone
else. He pleads with them to put
their guns down and chinwag it out
with him, which might have happened
if Bess hadn't burst out of the closet
with a mouth full of pointy canines
and a snarl instead of a "hello". Sam
accidentally cuts her with a silver
blade and her skin sizzles.
And that, boys and girls, is pretty
much the last resemblance you'll see
to almost anything this show has
considered canon for its werewolves
in the past 7 years.
That's right, werewolves. Bess is a
werewolf and Garth loves her
unconditionally. Garth is a werewolf
and loves her too. See Garth was
bitten on a hunt; he had his last
meal and was ready to aerate his
cranium when Bess sniffed him out
and talked him down off the ledge.
Oh, is that this a theme? Are we
being thematic? Or is it an accident?
I'm honestly not sure.
He didn't call because he was
embarrassed. Easier to bail than to
deal. Now, however, he's asking for
their trust. Bess, who is a natural
born werewolf, second generation off
the lycanthrope Mayflower, and her
pack are clean. No human
lunchables, four-legged and farm
fresh only, and if they don't believe
him, well they can just come over
and join the pack's prayer hour.
"They" is apparently just Dean. Yes,
Sam and Dean somehow decide that
the best plan is for Dean to go hang
out with a house full of werewolves
alone while Sam investigates...
something at the police station. Who
knows what? Does it matter?
Dean gets to meet all of Bess' family:
her father, her cousins, her
stepmother, and they're all just like
you'd imagine a wolf pack to be,
assuming you imagine them to be
stereotypical holy rollers who just
stepped out of a 1981 Sears,
Roebuck & Co. catalogue. Bess'
father, Reverend Jim, is the pack
alpha and welcomes Dean with open
arms. Dean resists ripping them off.
The good reverend offers to break
bread with Dean and show him how
they are more alike than different. On
one hand, it's awfully nice of them to
overcook a steak for him, it's like
making a vegan option when 99% of
the dinner party is gonna be eating
mac n' cheese, on the other hand
he's a little turned off by the giant
raw animal hearts they're chowing
on. And for a civilized group of
werewolves, some of these guys have
atrocious table manners, but hey, no
one put their elbows on the table.
They also all have a snazzy
accessory: a silver bullet on a chain
around their necks. Yeah, that's not
cult-y at all. They explain that it's to
remind them that they are not
invincible creatures, that they have
their weaknesses. The reverend also
tells Dean about how a hunter killed
his wife and he wanted revenge, but
realized the road to revenge is dark
and lonely and empty and blah, blah,
blah, we get it, it's another thematic
lesson.
Sam is off talking to the local sheriff,
digging into the family, but the worst
thing the sheriff calls them is
hippies. Sam pushes; asking if
anything weird ever happens in this
town, but the sheriff claims it's a
sleepy town with a decent record.
Back to Dean. He's lecturing Garth
on this lifestyle choice, he doesn't
trust it and frankly it's not just
because they're werewolves. Garth
tells him that with this experience
he's figured it all out: love and family
are what matters, no matter the form.
He also tells Dean that he thought it
was best for everyone, Dean, Sam,
Kevin, if he stayed away. Oh, look,
another lesson. And another. Excuse
me while I go grab an icepack for my
head.
Dean takes this opportunity to gruffly
relay that Kevin is dead and that he's
shouldering the full responsibility
with a vast oversimplification of the
situation. I think I actually saw his
beard grow an eighth of an inch.
Sam and Dean meet to recap, but are
interrupted by a call from the sheriff.
He's got a weird one for Sam, an
eviscerated deer carcass. Whatever
could have done this? Oh, it was the
sheriff, who despite us not knowing
his full lineage, apparently doesn't
need a lunar cycle to shift. He starts
to muahaha his plan out, but Dean
bulls-eyes him in the heart before he
even gets going.
Hey remember a few years ago when
Madison had no control of her
shifting, was ruled by the moon, was
completely not cognizant of her
behavior as a wolf, and Sam literally
put her down like a dog? Then later
we learned that all monsters came
from an original Alpha and could shift
not just during, but around the lunar
cycle, but only if they are pureblood?
If you do remember all that, it would
behoove you to forget it.
Now we're going to go the way of
Ragnarok, because it's engraved onto
the sheriff's bullet pendant, and if I
wanted an Avengers lesson I'd read
the comics, I'm a DC kind of gal, so
nah. I guess I'll let Dean fill me in.
I will say that at least Dean has off
the cuff knowledge going on here, we
rarely see that and that's a shame.
They split up; Sam breaks into Bess
and Garth's home while Dean breaks
into the Reverend Jim's office. Bess
and Garth's place is a mess, clearly
they were wolfnapped. Dean finds
more info on Ragnarok. End of days,
Odin, Fenris, gaping maw, prepare for
total domination, spirit fingers, you
get the idea. Unfortunately, Dean's
studying is interrupted by the
reverend, who says he knows Dean
is there because he can hear his
heart beating nervously, a lifetime of
hunting and he still gets the flutters.
Remember that, because I'm going to
bring it up again.
Anyway, the reverend defends his
stance; Ragnarok is a cautionary tale,
not a call to arms. In fact, his bullet
is etching free.
Oh by the way, Sam got knocked out
and kidnapped. When this is all over,
I want a scientist to study Sam
Winchester's amazing rubber
cranium.
Dean tries calling Sam, but Sam isn't
answering. He speeds over to the
main cult house and sneaks up on
Russ the werewolf henchman as he
stands guard outside. Because
suddenly Dean's heart is steady?
Silent? Did you know that under ideal
conditions wolves have a hearing
range of six miles away in the forest?
These conditions look ideal to me,
but Russ, not so much with the
canine lupine hearing. Wonder what
generation he was?
Bess' stepmom had tried to be good,
but a hunter killed her little brother
and now, you guessed it, she's on a
path to revenge.
Get yourself an Advil as a treat.
Now she's out to prove her
dedication to sparkle motion. Unlike
the sheriff she gets the chance to
exposition about her plan. She's
going to kill Garth and Bess and pin
it on Sam, but Sam, who is no longer
unconscious, gracefully kicks the
gun out of her hand. The man is
nearly 6'5", you'd think people would
tie his legs down.
Let's rewind a bit. Evil stepmom lays
out plan and Sam says, "you're
gonna frame their murders on me."
What even is that line?
Anyway, ever the resourceful hunter
Dean dons Russ' jacket to mask his
sent, it also apparently muffles the
sound of his beating heart, and
infiltrates the barn. Evil stepmom
doesn't even get the chance to bore
us again before Dean shoots her
through the heart.
The next day Sam and Dean get ready
to head out. Sam leaves Garth with a
simple, "be good" and a hug. Dean,
on the other hand, gets to have his
moment with someone not Sam.
Garth suggests coming back into the
fold, using his werewolf abilities to
give them an edge while hunting and
to atone for abandoning Kevin. Kevin
was his friend, you don't abandon
friends. I'm starting to feel like Sam
with all these whacks upside the
head.
Dean declines Garth's offer; love,
family, whatever it is, it's worth
fighting for, worth staying for.
The technical term for that pain in
your head that you fell is
"cephalagia".
Dean drives Sam back to his car (by
the way, where did Sam get this
vehicle??) and Sam gruffly bids Dean
ado, but Dean stops him. He wants
to talk about the night they broke up,
or as Sam likes to accurately refer to
it, "the night you left me". Fair
enough, the point is that Dean wants
to come home and be a family again.
Sam will allow it, hell, it's Dean's
home as much as it is his. And they
can hunt together, too, but that's
where Sam toes a line in the dirt, he
isn't at a place where he can call
Dean his brother right now. And with
that, Sam gets back into the Impala
and they, presumably, drive home.
Wait? What?
That brother thing is the one thing
here that isn't negotiable. You can
say you can't hunt together, you can
say you can't live together, but you
can't cheat DNA, you can't cheat a
lifetime of tripping over each other's
shadows.
Furthermore, would it kill Dean to
actually apologize for what he did?
All this guilt and responsibility, yeah,
he's shouldering it, but wrongly.
And Sam, well, he has every single
right to be upset with how Dean did
what he did, and good on him for
voicing it, but the fact remains that
comatose!Sam said "yes". In that
moment, when Dean/Ezekiel/Gadreel
pleaded his case, Sam chose Dean
and life. Heck, he made that choice
back in that church.
I don't usually step this far out of the
episode in my recaps, but this? What
was this episode? This is what I
learned: If Dean is sad, Dean can't
shave, maybe because he'll slit his
own throat. Sam has clearly taken
too many hits to the head and is
incapable of speaking for more than
two minutes at a time and when he
does he makes little to no sense, but
on the upside, souled or soulless
Sam Winchester digs a sweet Dodge.
And subtly is so 2008.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Supernatural 912
Review: Sharp Teeth


The back end of season 9 has had a
marked increase in quality over the
first half. The two episodes we've
had so far have shown progress on
many of the issues that I've found
problematic in the previous episodes
and I have high hopes that the show
is going to get back on track. Though
they weren't perfect, they were
certainly better in many ways. This
episode looked as though it was
going to further resolve some of the
issues that I've been having with the
season, but ultimately it didn't deliver
to the full extent I would have liked to
have seen. Overall I found the
episode to be lacking in many areas.
It wasn't very exciting for me and
didn't push the overarching plot or
character development as far as it
could have. There were positive
steps towards resolutions for many
of the issues, but they felt ultimately
incomplete.
The brothers talking to each other
and actually telling the truth was a
refreshing change of pace. Their lies
and separation are getting tiring so I
take these scenes as a step forward
for their characters this season. It
looked like the brothers were going
to finally going to get back in step
with each other. They were being
honest, essentially reunited, and
working on the same case, albeit not
at the exact same time. They even
drove off together at the end, but the
conversation they had with one
another right before the credits rolled
felt like it stopped short of where it
needed to be. There's still a lot of
tension there and, while it seems like
this would be a great source of
drama within the narrative, it's been
done far too much to be effective.
I think most people can agree that
the brothers being at odds with each
other is getting tiring. It was
dramatic and had an impact at first,
but it happens every season and it's
becoming predictable. They'll have
fights. They'll disagree. They'll
separate for an episode or two. Then
they'll get back together and hug it
out by the time the finale rolls
around. It was a strong narrative the
first time, but now it's weak and
overplayed. We want the Winchesters
on good terms, now. Most of us
don't want their tension to span for
many more episodes. The world the
writers have created is vast and, if
they wouldn't keep killing off all their
secondary characters, there would be
a lot more interpersonal drama to
draw from.
In the interest of full disclosure, I
simply don't like Garth as a character
very much. The quirks that many find
charming strike me as annoying. I've
also had several bad interactions
with the actor on Twitter which has
severely tainted my view of the
character. Despite this, I do find the
situation they put him in for the
episode quite interesting and it was
certainly not a path I expected the
character to go down. Problems with
the character and actor aside, I do
applaud them doing something like
this that I would have never
predicted. It further emphasizes the
fine line between human and monster
that comes up every so often on the
show. It's a complex issue with lots
of ground to cover within the
narrative. Being a monster, whether
it's a werewolf or vampire or almost
anything else, can push a human to
reject their humanity. Some people,
however, cling to their humanity and
actively fight to retain a sense of
right and wrong. It's not simply black
and white and whenever Supernatural
attempts to tackle that issue it grabs
my attention.
While Dean's initial distrust of the
werewolf cult eventually turned out to
be partially founded, his attitude
towards them was rather surprising
to me. In season 6 Dean had a run in
as a vampire and I thought that had
given him a different perspective on
the whole human-monster
dichotomy. I expect him to be slightly
more sympathetic towards these
situations. His interactions with
Lenore and Benny should have also
contributed to this. While he was
definitely filled with self hate when
he was a vampire, he recognized that
he was still essentially Dean
Winchester at his core, though his
body was being driven by very
inhuman urges. He was raised as a
hunter, though. It's ingrained into his
psyche to treat monsters as
creatures to be exterminated. As
previously mentioned, it's a complex
issue and while I would like Dean to
take a more complex look at each
individual monster before ganking
them, he was raised to view it as a
black and white issue and that's not
an easy thing to get past.
Bess was also rather refreshing. I
fully expected her to die or turn out
to be evil, but neither happened. She
survived intact and still likeable. The
same can't be said of her mother,
but Bess was the one of the two we
were meant to attach to and I'm glad
they spared her. She wasn't given
much depth in the episode, but time
was short and for what she was
given she was generally a likeable
character. If they bring Garth back
perhaps she'll be given a chance to
return as well. I wish Bess and Garth
the best of luck in their future wolfy
relationship.
Overall this episode did take steps in
the right direction, but the steps
weren't large enough to be ultimately
satisfying. The fact that the episode
wasn't grossly offensive makes it
decent in comparison, but I expect
more from this show. So far the latter
half of the season has been a huge
improvement, but this episode
seemed to falter a bit. I hope it's not
a sign that the season is losing it's
forward momentum.
HaymurS thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Let's Speculate: Supernatural
9x12 - "Sharp Teeth"


Warning : If you have not seen
tonight's episode, "Sharp Teeth,"
then beware spoilers ahead! (From
Alice - please take the snark you're
about to read in good humored fun.)
Summary: This episode opens with
Farmer Jim plowing out of his house
because someone's tipping cows in
his pasture. He shoots at the
cowtipper, who runs through the
woods like he just figured out that
Gretel was dinner. Cowtipper gets hit
by a car and lo and behold we see
that cowtipper is our own puppet
loving, normalized hunter Garth.
The episode follows the nearly
divorced Winchesters as they meet
up in a hospital room to look over
the recently absent Garth. I figure
they must have invested some money
in the hospital set so we got to use
it, right? Awkward, in need of
counseling Winchesters wake up
Sleeping Beauty and he freaks out.
He escapes and the brothers agree
to try and find him together. At this
point, though, I will say that a
miracle occurred in Dean being
honest about his mark of Cain tattoo.
He didn't lie and say it was the
product of a drunken encounter with
a hooker and her tattoo loving pimp.
He admitted it was the mark of Cain
and Sam cared for about two
seconds. No bigs, right?
Anyway, fast forward through Dean
trying to shake Sam off the case and
Sam being like nuh-uh Mr. Sandman
and we find out that Garth is married
to a resident of MTV's newest hit
show and is himself a not-so-Teen
Wolf. They belong to the Stepford
Wolves Club where you wear bullets
with your pantaloons and eat beast
for supper. Also, if you didn't get it,
Reverend Jim is trying to achieve
peace with the humans even though
the humans killed his wife. You see,
John Winchester again fails. Fails in
analogy. (Note: This John
Winchester brought to you by the
writer of abandoning John, bad father
John, and the maker of Kristy.)
Dean proceeds to have an
uncomfortable dinner filled with
blood, guts, and the destruction of
the last thing in the world he was
holding sacred. No, not the
brotherhood. Pie. Pie is now forever
destroyed. RIP Pie.
As the mystery unfolds, Dean
encounters a rabid sheriff looming
over the carcass of Bambi's mother.
Sam shows up and Sheriff tries to kill
them but brojo (Brother Mojo) wins
out. Too bad that's the only time we
see it this episode. So Dean's all like
we need to kill Garth and Sam's like
whoa there buckaroo, let's think this
through. Dean's like whatever, okay. I
have a gorgeous Ginger Beard that
will protect me from your wily ways,
Sam Winchester. Anyway, Sam splits
to go get Garth while Dean goes to
confront "You Coulda Been John
Winchester" Reverend. Dean wants to
kill him but the marvel of his ginger
beard makes him stop and consider
and as he already has a soft spot for
letting werewolves go...well you
know what happens. Back to Sam
and we get to see him suffer his
5414th blow to the head. He now can
sign up for the NFL concussion
insurance group. Finally.
In an homage to "The Benders" and
Glass's season seven "Adventures in
Babysitting," Sam gets tied up like a
girl to a 1910s railroad track and the
train is Alpha Wife female who does
not like the whole peace loving
humanity of her husband. They gots
an apocalypse to get going - All Hail
Fenrir! So in this week's mythology
arc, we get to return to Norse
Mythology but without Loki, which is
no real Norse mythology at all. Just
saying. She does some monologue
about humans being bad, destructive
- the usual demon, pagan god, angel
rhetoric about humanity. Garth tries
to turn 1980s Michael J. Fox while
Sam ponders when Ginger Beard will
arrive, which right on cue, he does!
GingerDean! to the rescue! The
magical powers of his facial hair
empower him to stab cousin Daryl
Wolf with a silver blade and then turn
on the worst version of a stepmother
since Germany circa 17th century
fairytellings. Stepmonster gets
ganked and all is well...until...
Final scenes are Garth centric
apologizing for Kevin's death but
GingerDean is so GuiltDean and takes
on that blame on his own. There's
awkward guest star hugging like last
week and then the much heralded
Bob Singer talk on the Impala trope
- this time Sam basically disowns
Dean. I have many feelings at this
scene and will hold my commentary.
And my argument that we are smack
back in the middle of seasons four
and five lives on.
Next week: Costumes.
What I Liked:
1. Garth return. I miss Mr. Fizzles
though. Fail, show.
2. Ginger Beard!
3. Ragnarok was a pretty cool
reference. I am a fan of the Prose
and Poetic Eddas.
What I Didn't Like:
1. Sam not really caring about the
mark of CAIN? It was like a two
second reaction? Really? Has
Soulless returned and no one told
me????
2. Sam's disavowal of Dean. No.
Just NO.
3. SAM. Stop it, show. Stop doing
this to Sam.
Questions of the week since I have
no speculations:
So will the mark of Cain have any
effect or is it simply a mark?
Is Sam simply mad or is this some
narrative turn the show is making in
the brothers' relationship?
Will Garth and Bess have wolf
babies?
And where the hell is Crowley?!
Please share your feelings, theories,
and thoughts below.
(From Alice - Reminder of the rules.
Keep it positive and constructive. I
know this wasn't a stellar ep, so
joking around about some things is
okay, but no excessive negativity or
disrespect of other posters. That's all
I ask!)