I have three more to add now .. 😃
1. " Harry- The unintended Horcrux" - i need some insights on this one from my fellow potterheads because I totally dont get what happened there & how it ended..😕.. so as it happens , Voldy split his soul into 7 pieces & voldy wanted it to be the magical number 7 , and there were seven horcuxes including Harry.. so my first question here is - was Voldy aware that Harry too was his horcux ?.. it is highly unlikely as it has been brought up several times in the book that Voldy had no idea about it, if he did, he would have probably kept Harry locked up in an enchanted cage forever instead of killing him 🤢..so if Voldy wasnt aware that Harry was a horcrux, why did he stop with Nagini?.. bcoz for him , Nagini would be only 6th horcrux, right? & he wanted it to be 7..so i was half expecting him to create 8 horcruxes instead of 7 due to miscalculation..hmm.. may be he couldnt find time in the midst of all that was going on..🤔...
2." Harry- The unintended Horcrux"- My second question regarding this is, how come Harry returned from the afterlife ?.. I think i remember Hermoine describing horcruxes ( correct me if i am wrong) as something that is exactly opposite to the concept of "Human body & Soul".. a human body (container of soul) is mortal whereas the soul is immortal but in the case of horcrux , this law is entirely reversed, the part of the soul contained in the Horcrux is only as mortal or immortal as the horcrux container it self, meaning, if one destroys the horcrux container one destroys the part of the soul hidden in it & that is why , it is extremely difficult to destroy a Horcrux bcoz the soul hidden inside it is only as strong as the container as opposed to Human body which is very easy to destroy but the soul inside remains unharmed.. so now what i want to know is , how come Harry's body ( the container or Horcrux) was able to survive when the part of Voldy's soul hidden inside it was destroyed ?.. Harry's body defied all logic that was applicable to all other 6 horcruxes ( including Nagini, a living being like Harry ).. going by horcrux logic, if Harry's body remained unharmed , it means the part of Voldy's soul hidden inside it too remained unharmed, but what happened in the book was exact opposite without a supporting logic whatsoever...one possible explanation here could be that Voldy's Soul inside Harry's body was destroyed using "Avada Kadavra" curse which keeps the body intact as opposed to other horcruxes which were killed using the only known weapons to kill horcruxes..Nagini was the only other horcrux apart from Harry who was a being, all others were objects, so we would have got a better insight into this phenomenon if Nagini too was killed using the death curse instead of getting her head sliced off..🤢..😆..and yes, it seems that horcruxes inside a living container can be destroyed with Avada Kadavra, no need of Basilisk Venom here.. but even so, purely going by horcrux logic as explained above, it seems illogical that Harry should be able return from afterlife unharmed.. ur thoughts?..
3. "
Felix Felicis "- Commonly known as
Liquid Luck- Now there you have it !..A Perfect solution to ALL the problems !!.. and yet practically absent when needed the most without any proper explanation.. JKR admitted the loophole created by Time Turners but somehow that has not been the case with liquid luck..why?.. JKR did put forth the side effects of this potion - "
It is meant to be used sparingly, however, as it causes giddiness, recklessness, and dangerous overconfidence if taken in excess. Felix is highly toxic in large quantities and is also a banned substance in all organised competitions, such as Quidditch, along with all other methods of cheating. It is very difficult to make, disastrous if made wrong, and requires six months to stew before it is ready to be consumed. "..but even so, it doesnt seem like it could be that dangerous if proper precautions were to be taken.. sometimes i think, why couldnt Dumbledore leave behind huge stack of Felix Felicis with proper instructions instead of those useless, unnecessary puzzles for the leading trio..😆 ..our heroes could have used a wee bit of luck for completing the mission left behind by Dumbly !..⭐️...Alas, that wasnt the case & no explanations either !.
comment:
p_commentcount